Tag Archives: Mostly Autumn

The Sound of the World

It may be that social networking has killed the webforum, but HippyDave, who already runs the official Panic Room and Stolen Earth forums has started a new forum The Sound of the World, dedicated to Mostly Autumn and the extended family of side projects and related bands. It has sections for Mostly Autumn, Halo Blind, Morpheus Rising and for Heather Findlay’s solo career, as well as past projects such as Odin Dragonfly, Josh and Co, and Breathing Space.

It’s a matter of debate as to whether or not the world really needs yet another Mostly Autumn forum. As HippyDave himself explains, a great many people, including a lot of dedicated fans, have issues with the way the official forum is over-moderated. There is already an unofficial forum, but that suffers from the opposite problem in that it’s under-moderated and tends to get overrun by trolls. There isn’t a place online where you can have a serious discussion about their music without the constant feeling that you’re walking on eggshells.

Time will tell if the forum gets a critical mass of regular posters and hosts meaningful discussions about the bands’ music.

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Mostly Autumn - Still Beautiful

“Still Beautiful” is Mostly Autumn’s third live album in three years. A cynic might accuse them of milking the fanbase with yet another live release, but the success of last year’s “That Night In Leamington” and the two disks of “Live 2009″ does suggest there’s a market for a live document of every tour. This one is significant as it’s the first to feature Olivia Sparnenn as the band’s lead vocalist.

Let’s get the one negative out of the way first; the packaging isn’t terribly inspiring, with very little about the band apart from a black and white photo of each band member. Very little too in the way of credits and nothing about when or where it was recorded. It’s been criticised for looking like a bootleg, and those criticisms can’t easily be dismissed.

But the actual quality of the album is anything but an official bootleg; they’ve taken a lot of care mixing and mastering this. The huge sound of the seven-piece band is immensely powerful. If you’ve seen the band live on the 2011 spring tour you’ll know just how good they’ve been, and this recording captures all that energy and intensity, if anything better than on “Live 2009″. If you haven’t had the chance to see them live, you’ll hear what you’ve been missing; they really have been that good.

The running order is odd, bearing little resemblance to the actual running order on the tour. I think the whole set is present bar “Fading Colours” and “Spirit of Autumn Past”, drawing heavily from the most recent album “Go Well Diamond Heart” including a couple of songs from the second disk of the now sold-out special edition, including the beautiful “Forever Young”.

This album showcases new vocalist Olivia Sparnenn’s power and range as a vocalist. In her second year fronting the band her interpretation of oldies such as “Evergreen”, “Passengers” or “Caught in a Fold” proves that the back catalogue is in safe hands, and her performance on newer songs written for her voice is stunning. Perhaps the high spot on the entire album is the powerful and intense “Questioning Eyes”, the former Breathing Space number now a fixture in Mostly Autumn’s set.

If you’re a Mostly Autumn fan you will want this album. If you’re not familiar with their music, this is as good a place to start as any. The album is available now from Mostly Autumn records.

Posted in Music, Record Reviews | Tagged | 2 Comments

Cambridge Rock Festival 2011 - Part Three

Sunday began with wall of guitar rock and roll from Empire of Fools, who played some highly melodic hard rock, with plenty of light and shade, with a couple of Deep Purple and Free covers thrown in for good measure. Next up was Final Conflict, the first of many prog-rock acts on the bill. Nothing ground-breaking, but they displayed some tight musicianship with a good groove to many of their songs, and rocked out pretty hard by the end of the set.

Jebo weren’t quite as good; another melodic hard(ish) rock band they started well but soon got a bit predictable. Although good musicians with a great guitar sound, they suffered from weak vocals and a shortage of memorable songs. Crimes of Passion were a little better, but having seen Kyrbgrinder on Friday, their brand of 70s metal came over as very dated by comparison.

Credo, on the other hand, were a lot better. Again, there was nothing stunningly original about their brand of neo-prog, but they did it well. Their combination of very strong melodies, tight playing with a lot of fluid symphonic guitar went down well.

I enjoyed the John Young Band set too. I’ve seen him before as a support act, using just keys and backing tapes and was quite impressed. His full band including former Fish sidesman Robin Boult on guitar opens out the sound a lot more. He played another very prog-flavoured set, although this time more focussed on impassioned songwriting rather than showcasing instrumental virtuosity.

I was starting to suffer from neo-prog overload by the time Mr So-and-So came on stage. Yes, they too were good, but for me they suffered from sounding too similar to the preceding bands on the bill. One significant difference was the presence of Charlotte Evans on vocals, even though she largely sang harmonies and only sang lead on a couple of songs.

Good as many of the previous bands of the day had been, Mostly Autumn were in a completely different league, and it showed. This was the fourth consecutive year they’ve played this festival. Last year they’d headlined, though good, they didn’t really reach the heights that they’re capable of and special guests The Enid rather stole the show. Not so this time around. Now the band have finally manage some lineup stability they’ve been on consistently great form all year. Over the past year and a half Olivia Sparnenn has had time to grow into the role of frontwoman. Two weeks ago they owned the Classic Rock Presents Prog stage at the High Voltage festival in London and won over a lot of new fans; this performance had the same level of intensity, and finally showed the Cambridge Rock Festival just what this band are really capable of.

On form like this their mix of melodic hard rock with celtic-tinged progressive rock makes for a great festival band. The set was a mix of old and new, standards like “Evergreen” and “Heroes Never Die” alongside newer songs like “Deep in Borrowdale” and “Ice”. High spots for me were Anne-Marie’s flute solo in “The Last Climb”, and a very powerful performance of the former Breathing Space epic “Questioning Eyes”. Yes, I know I’m a big fan, and therefore biased, but I’ve seen them enough times to tell a great performance from a merely workmanlike one. That was truly memorable set, for all the right reasons.

Caravan, veterans of the 1970s “Canterbury Scene”, had also played an excellent set at High Voltage. Like Mostly Autumn before them, they were every bit as good as they had been two weeks ago, a superb set of jazz-flavoured progressive rock, keyboard-led with added violin, flute and spoons(!). They pulled off the seemingly impossible feat of sounding mellow yet full of energy at the same time, and lengthy instrumental jazz-rock workouts seldom sounded as good as this. Not that they don’t do pop as well, as the bouncy rendition of “Golf Girl” proved. High point had to be the lengthy “Nine Feet Undergound” played in it’s entirety.

And finally, headliners The Enid. Last year they played a mesmerising set focussing on their rockier material, and while not everyone really got what they were doing, some of those that did felt they were the band of the weekend. This year, accompanied by a male choir and a twelve-piece brass section they went for something a lot more challenging. For the first part of the set, Robert John Godfrey was behind the choir, visible on the large screens but hidden from view when you tried to find him on the stage, which was a little disconcerting. The sound was huge and symphonic, but came over as perhaps just too ambitious for it’s own good. I did get the impression it was the sort of performance, which while good, seemed to me geared more towards the dedicated fan rather than a festival audience. I can imagine a lot of people not familiar with their rather unique blend of rock and classical music struggling to make sense of it all. It certainly didn’t have the energy level than made the closing stages of last year’s set so exhilarating. Perhaps to compensate they closed with their famous “Dambusters March/Land of Hope and Glory” medley they used to play back in the 1980s, to end the set on a high.

And so ended another great festival, probably the best Cambridge Rock Festival I’ve attended to date. Although Saturday turned out to be by far the best of the three days bill-wise, there were more than enough good acts on Friday and Sunday to make the whole weekend worthwhile.

Although it’s never easy to estimate numbers, I thought attendance was well up on last year; certainly the main tent was very full on both Saturday and Sunday nights, and even Thursday night drew a big crowd. It shows a festival doesn’t need big-name headliners to be a success, and provided a far more enjoyable experience than a big corporate festival, a great example of the little niche festivals up and down the country that take place below the radar of the media. And while some may criticise the lineup for being dated and retro, that’s surely part of the appeal; a good festival is one that knows it’s audience. It’s got a great vibe; no rock star egos or VIP areas; you find many of the artists wandering around the site or watching other bands all weekend; I even spotted the lead guitarist of one band enthusiastically playing air-guitar in the front row at one point.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

High Voltage 2011

The High Voltage festival, held in Victoria Park in east London, is now in it’s second year. It’s focus is very much on classic rock, progressive rock and metal. Last years festival, headlined by ZZ Top and ELP was a fantastic weekend. This year’s bill has attracted some criticism for being weaker than last year, but still contained enough great bands to well worth attending.

For some of us at least, the weekend began on Friday with The Reasoning playing a packed Borderline in central London. The slimmed-down five piece incarnation of the band has gelled well now, even though the mix was little vocal-heavy with not quite enough guitar. Their set was an well-chosen selection of songs from their three albums with most of the classics accounted for, plus a couple of excellent sounding brand new numbers from their forthcoming new album, “The Omega Point”, and “No Friend of Mine”, which is apparently all about the pitfalls of social media. I just hope the lyrics are not about me! A great show, which turned out to be the first ever gig by a band I’ve known personally that completely sold out.

High Voltage itself opened on Saturday lunchtime with Von Hertzen Brothers on the Classic Rock Presents Prog stage. Not a band I knew much about. They started off playing melodic hard rock; good, but I wondered what they were doing on the prog stage. But as the set progressed they began playing some more complex material with intricate harmonies that more than justified their inclusion. Tight, energetic and melodic, a good start to the day.

Next up, the much-acclaimed Amplifier, from the more avant-garde end of the genre. The opening moments sounded like The Fall, all atonal noise, but after a few seconds, actual tunes started to appear. Their set was dense and riffy with a lot of atmosphere. By no means bad, but I’m not sure I’ve completely got my head round their music. This lot may take more listening before I really appreciate what they’re doing.

Canterbury scene veterans Caravan represented the opposite end of the spectrum of progressive rock. I wasn’t quite sure what to expect from them, but they far exceeded whatever expectations I had. They played a great jazz-influenced set, keyboard-led with plenty of flute and violin, including the bouncy pop-rock of “Golf Girl”, and ending with the lengthy workout of “Nine Feet Underground” from their seminal album “The Land of the Grey and Pink”. Excellent stuff, and I can’t wait to see them again at the Cambridge Rock Festival.

Liverpool’s Anathema are very much the prog band of the moment. They started off life as a death-metal band, but there’s little or no trace of that now in their atmospheric indie-flavoured prog sound. This is a band who have toiled away for years before getting the recognition they deserved. Their triumphal set, drawn largely from the latest and best album “We’re Here Because We’re Here”, was simply stunning.

Neal Morse turned out to be the revelation of the day. I’ve admired his work with Spock’s Beard, but haven’t investigated his more recent solo work. With an eight-piece band including electric violin and electric cello(!), he played with an incredible level of energy and enthusiasm. The music was a lot like earlier Spock’s Beard, quirky but hugely melodic, with a clear nod to Gentle Giant. The very religious lyrics were a bit hard to take, even for me, but if you focus on the music, it’s amazing and heady stuff, and it was impossible not to be moved by the sheer exuberance of his performance.

I was wondering just how John Lees Barclay James Harvest could follow that. But I needn’t have worried. I’m a late convert to BJH, loving their huge soaring Mellotron-drenched sound. Even without the late Woolly Wolstenholme, and now playing as a four-piece, they’re a great live band. Their distinctive stately symphonic rock culminated in the magnificent epic “The Poet/After the Day”, surely their equivalent of Mostly Autumn’s “Mother Nature”. They closed, as they always do with “Hymn”, which turned into a singalong.

After than it was a quick sprint over to the main stage to catch the hellfire and brimstone of headliners Judas Priest. Amazingly, despite owning a great many of their albums, I’ve never seen this genre-defining band live. Despite their age, the Black Country metal veterans rocked, and even at 60 years old Rob Halford has still got it vocally with those piercing screams. Their greatest hits set drew from right across their 40-year back catalogue, from their very early years to the title track of the most recent opus “Nostradamus”, which Halford sung dressed in a cape and hood. This is a band who really understand the art of showmanship, with Halford whipping the Harley-Davison during “Hell Bent For Leather”. Camper than Millets, but great fun. And what a setlist! Early epics like “Victim of Changes” and “Beyond the Realms of Death”, 80s hit singles like “Breaking the Law”, the controversial “Turbo” and more recent songs like “Judas Rising” from “Angel of Retribution”.

Sunday started with some old-school neo-prog from 80s veterans Pallas, who played an energetic and enthusiastic set, a great warm-up for the day. While much of the set came from their more recent albums I’m not familiar with, they ended with a rousing rendition of “Arrive Alive”.

There is no-one else quite like The Enid, led by keyboard wizard Robert John Godfrey. Not everyone gets what they do, essentially classical music played on rock instrumentation. Supplemented this time by a small choir and a four-piece trumpet section, their set was over far too quickly, ending with the medley of “Land of Hope and Glory” and The Dambusters March, which RJG took pains to suggest was being performed at the request of the promoters. All stirring stuff, and I’m looking forward to seeing them headline the Cambridge Rock Festival.

Curved Air are another band I was looking forward to seeing. Like Caravan, they’re a classic 70s band reformed in recent years, and like them, they’ve still got it decades later. Sonja Kristina was on excellent form vocally, still looking glamorous despite being a grandmother. Apart from their hit “Back Street Luv” and “Vivaldi”, both of which they played, I knew nothing of their back catalogue. They’re very much at the jazzy end of prog with electric violin central to their sound - this is certainly a band I want to see again.

Then it was fingers crossed for Mostly Autumn, for what was a very high profile gig for them. I know I’m a huge fan, and likely to be biased, but it was clear this was something out of the ordinary, even by the high standards of their shows this year. It was one of the performances of their lives. They completely owned the stage, with a mix of energy and emotional intensity that few bands can match. They deserve to pick up a lot of new fans on the strength of performances like that.

Spocks Beard were, for me at least, the sole disappointment of the festival. Maybe it was because I was watching them from further back, maybe it was because they had to follow Mostly Autumn’s stunning performance, maybe having Ted Leonard standing in for the unavailable Nick D’Virgilio on lead vocals sapped their energy. Despite playing a set drawing heavily from their earliest and best albums, they just failed to engage me at all. It all seemed flat – there was none of the jubilant enthusiasm of Neal Morse’s set the day before. I left before the end to catch Black Country Communion on the main stage, so missed Neal’s appearance at the end of the set – maybe that finally brought things to life.

Black Country Communion, on the other hand, absolutely rocked with the sort of performance that’s in danger of giving supergroups a good name. I’d seen Glenn Hughes fronting his own band last year, which was good, and proved his vocal chords are still in good working order. But when he’s sharing the stage with genuine rock stars rather than journeyman musos, BCC are in a completely different league. Joe Bonamassa is the axe hero of his generation, and is the perfect foil for Hughes’ still-superb voice. Jason Bonham is a chip off the old block on drums, and Derek Sherinian added huge depth to the sound on Hammond organ. They ended with an absolutely barnstorming cover of Deep Purple’s “Burn”.

I only caught the last few songs of Jethro Tull, so I can’t really give a thorough appraisal of their set. But I did see rousing renditions of “Aqualung” and “Locomotive Breath” with Joe Bonamassa guesting.

Finally, festival headliners Dream Theater. Even if their brand of intensely muso prog-metal isn’t your cup of tea, every band on the prog stage owes a debt to them. More than any other band, Dream Theater are responsible for putting progressive rock back on the map, and without them many other bands wouldn’t be there. This was a high-stakes gig for them, marking the debut of new drummer Mike Mangini, replacing the much-loved Mike Portnoy.

This is a band who have always been far more about the musicians than the singer. In theatre-sized venues where you can actually see the band members hands, they’re actually quite exciting to watch, fingers flying up and down fretboards. But in a large arena where you can only really see the band on the big screens at the sides of the stage, that effect gets lost. Vocalist James LaBrie was actually on quite good form for once – while he’s never going to be one of my favourite singers, this time his vocals weren’t nearly as bad as I feared they’d be.

While there’s no doubting the band’s amazing technical skills, there was little of the showmanship we’d seen with Judas Priest the night before. The music was great, with a dense complex tapestry of sound. But it clearly didn’t appeal to everyone, and I noticed people were leaving in significant numbers before the end. Still a good performance, but in a weekend that had seen several outstanding ones, by no means the highlight of the weekend.

And so ended the festival. A weekend of amazing music, and a great gathering of the rock tribes. Loved the way I kept bumping into friends all weekend, not just fellow fans but people like Kim Seviour from Touchstone and Ian Jones from Karntaka. Having spent most of the weekend in front of the Classic Rock Presents Prog stage, the sheer quality and variety of the music says it all about why I love progressive rock as a genre. Amplifier are nothing like Mostly Autumn who are nothing like Anathema who are nothing like Neal Morse. Need I go on? Got to an indie festival and all you’ll get a slew of bands drawing from the same limited musical palette, all playing the same predictable chord progressions.

I’m now counting down days until the Cambridge Rock Festival in less than two weeks’ time.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Mostly Autumn at Bury

Mostly Autumn’s annual visit to Bury Met last month was the first time I’ve ever travelled to a gig by kettle. Bury Met used to be a local gig for me, but now I’ve moved down south. Because all the affordable hotels in Bury were full, I ended up staying in the delightfully-named town of Ramsbottom, reached by means of the East Lancashire Railway. May well be the first time I’ve used a preserved railway as a means of getting from A to B rather than just for the ride.

It does feel like I’ve I’m living the blog tagline here - especially when The Trackside Inn at Bury serves an excellent selection of real ales, including one brewed by The Phoenix Brewery.

I won’t write an in-depth review since I wrote one for Salisbury in April. But I will say the gig itself was another superb performance. The band are really on form on this tour, and Bury Met always has a great audience. Not for nothing did the band record this gig for a planned live album. Olivia Sparnenn is now far more confident as the band’s frontwoman, and everyone else was on great form too, aided by a really good mix.

As well as the sound, I’ve got to compliment the lighting engineer too. Often when photographing gigs I find some band members, especially Iain Jennings, get hidden in shadows at the side of the stage. This time it was possible to get good photos of everyone. even the drummer. I’ve put a lot more photos on my post-Fotopic photo site - http://kalyr.smugmug.com

Posted in Live Reviews, Music, Photos, Railways | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Mostly Autumn - Salisbury City Hall, 1st April 2011

Photo © Howard Rankin

On Friday, April 1st, Mostly Autumn played a special show in aid of the charity Pilgrim Bandits. The guest of honour was Ben Parkinson, a Mostly Autumn fan critically injured while serving in Afghanistan. The title track of “Go Well Diamond Heart” is dedicated to his story. Whatever your feeling on the rights and wrongs of the war in Afghanistan, you can’t fault his indomitable spirit in coping with something far more traumatic that most of us will ever face. “A man with a mountain on his back”, as the lyrics say.

I had a gut feeling this was going to be a very special event, and the band did not let us down.

The band chose a very interesting way to open the show. Instead of rolling an intro tape they began with keyboard player Iain Jennings alone on stage kicking off the looping rhythm track that heralds the instrumental “Distant Train”. The rest of the band came on stage one by one, first Anne-Marie on flute, then Bryan on guitar, until Olivia Sparnenn made her dramatic entrance as the band segued into “Answer the Question”.

What we witnessed over the next two and a half hours was a band absolutely on fire. Olivia Sparnenn has grown in self-confidence over the past year, and has now stamped her own personality on things. She’s taken older songs such as “Evergreen” or “Fading Colours” and made them hers, and really shines on the newer material written for her voice. Bryan Josh was on equally superb form on guitar, his solos alternately soaring and shredding with a style that transcends his obvious influences. It’s a very different Mostly Autumn to the band of a year ago, but on the strengths of performances like this, they’ve every bit as good as they were when fronted by Heather Findlay. And like all the best gigs, it was clear the band were enjoying every minute their time on stage, all seven members giving it everything to contribute to Mostly Autumn’s multi-layered and hugely melodic sound, benefiting from a mix in which you could hear every voice and instrument clearly.

The setlist was a near-perfect mix of old and new. Naturally the new album “Go Well Diamond Heart” featured very heavily, the band playing all but one song from the first disk plus the two obvious standouts from the bonus disk. “Forever Young” and the emotionally powerful “And When The War Is Over” are well on their way to becoming live favourites. It’s nice to hear “Violet Skies” played live at last, even if the shimmering pop number didn’t quite work as well live as I’d hoped. Given the amount of new material most of the older songs were the obvious standards, but the band still threw in a surprise in “First Thought”, a seldom-played song from “Passengers”. But yet again, one of the real high spots was the former Breathing Space epic “Questioning Eyes”.

Given the nature of the gig as a charity event rather than a stop on a regular tour, in a city the band have never played before, it was a different sort of audience, with a great many unfamiliar faces in the crowd. The band deserve to have picked up plenty of new fans. The only sad note was that so many of the former front-row regulars appear have stopped supporting the band since the change of singer a year ago - they really don’t know what they’re missing.

The band will be touring in May and June, culminating in some festival appearances in July and August. On this sort of form, they’re a band not to be missed.

Posted in Live Reviews, Music | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

Heart Full of Sky and Glass Shadows in Retrospect

There’s some truth in the idea that you only really judge an album after the release of it’s successor. So I’ve put together some thoughts on Mostly Autumn’s previous two albums, Heart Full of Sky and Glass Shadows, both of which met with decidedly mixed reactions from fans and critics when they first came out.

The pre-orders of “Heart Full of Sky” shipped at the end of 2006, with the retail edition following in February. The pre-order limited edition was a double album with a second disk of bonus material, one track of which was eventually to find it’s way on to the single-disk retail edition of the album.

It was the work of a band in something of a state of flux. With founder member Iain Jennings having left the band at the end of 2005, it’s the only one of Mostly Autumn’s albums to feature Chris Johnson on keys, who surprised quite a few people by becoming part of the creative core of the band, writing four songs and taking the lead vocals for two of them.

I think it’s fair to describe it as the album that most sharply divided opinion amongst fans. For every person that loves the album, there’s another who thinks it’s by far the worst thing the band have ever done.

It certainly has some good points. It does contain what I consider to be three absolute classics in “Fading Colours”, “Find the Sun” and “Silver Glass”, up there with anything else Mostly Autumn have recorded. Heather’s “Half a World”, notably the only song on the retail disk where she’s is credited with music as well as lyrics, and Bryan’s epic prog-guitar workout “Further From Home” are also pretty impressive. That’s half an album’s worth of great music, which I would suggest is greatly preferable to a whole album of merely average songs. And I have to say Heather’s vocal performances are superb throughout.

Unfortunately for me the rest of the album isn’t really in the same league. We’ve got possibly the most controversial song in MA’s entire catalogue, “Pocket Watch”. Some have claimed it had the potential to be a massive crossover hit, but I think another reviewer summed it up very well with “It sounds like that band that sounds like every other band…”. In other words, it’s generic landfill indie, not the sort of music Mostly Autumn ought to be playing. You can’t have a hit with a song like that unless it’s 1996 and your name is Noel Gallagher.

Other songs seem half-formed; some decent musical ideas and motifs, but they don’t quite work as well as they should as complete songs. “Ghost”, “Dreaming” and “Walk With a Storm” all end up sounding a little bit like Frankenstein’s Monsters of songs made up from bits. Some of the individual bits, like the “Sign at the edge of the road” refrain Heather sings in “Dreaming” are superb, but too often the whole isn’t as good as the sum of the parts.

The second bonus disk is an equally mixed bag; it’s got the beautiful “Yellow Time” which was to find a home on Odin Dragonfly’s “Offerings”, and Chris Johnson’s sublime “Gaze”, which really ought to have gone on the single disk retail edition. On the other hand, Chris’ “Science and Machinery”, while a good song, fitted as perfectly into Parade’s live set last September as it didn’t in Mostly Autumn’s set three years earlier. Other songs like “Bright Green” sound like little more than demos that needed more work to become album-quality songs.

The album’s other big flaw is the production; it’s suffered very badly in the so-called “Loudness Wars”, with far too much the dynamics squeezed out of the record. I’ve heard it described as “unlistenable”; I don’t think it’s quite that bad, but on a halfway decent stereo it does not sound good, something which is very very apparent when you listen to it and the following album “Glass Shadows” back-to-back. If any MA album is a candidate for remastering, it’s this one. There are certainly songs that many people might only start to appreciate if the music is allowed to breathe.

It may be that the band were trying to experiment with some new ideas; certainly songs like “Broken” and “Blue Light” explored completely new territory, and I really can’t quite make up my mind if they work or not. But the impression the album gives is that the band had stretched themselves too thin trying to record a double album in a limited time, and didn’t have time to hone the arrangements. Even that best song, “Fading Colours” has changed significantly since being recorded; all those big vocal harmonies that give it such an epic cinematic feel live weren’t on the original studio version, but were added during rehearsals for the tour. And with three songwriters not quite pulling in the same direction the whole thing doesn’t really hang together as a coherent album in the way “Glass Shadows” does. I think what I find really frustrating about Heart Full of Sky is that I see the potential for a far better album; there are too many good ideas which weren’t properly developed.

The overall verdict four years on is that this is a real curate’s egg of an album; when it’s good it’s very good indeed, but suffers from serious flaws that can easily end up overshadowing the good bits.

—-

“Glass Shadows” came out in the spring of the 2008. With Chris Johnson having left the band to work on the solo project that was later to become Parade, the band were down to a creative core of just Bryan and Heather, with Bryan playing almost all the keys as well the guitars.

In contrast to the compressed and overproduced sound of it’s predecessor, the album has a far more stripped-down organic sound, far closer to how the band sound live.

Songwriting-wise it’s far more solid, and hangs together strongly as a coherent album despite Heather’s songs taking a markedly different musical direction from Bryan’s. There’s no real filler, and material like the much-criticised “Pocket Watch” are mercifully absent. But I feel it does lack the sort of absolute classic song in the league of “Fading Colours” or “Carpe Diem” to lift the album to the next level. “Tearing at the Faerytale” and the lengthy title track do come close though, and Heather’s “Unoriginal Sin” really came to life on stage. Indeed, the emotionally-charged live versions were the high point of the first set on the tour, and Live 2009 contains the definitive version of that song.

Only a couple of the songs don’t quite work for me. “Fireside” has a really great riff, and builds nicely through the verse and the bridge, but then simply doesn’t go anywhere. A pity, because it feels like there’s a Mostly Autumn classic somewhere in there trying to get out. “A Different Sky” isn’t really a bad song, but just doesn’t fit the album at all, which would have been far better ending at “Until the Story Ends”. Seeing as the band subsequently released the song as a single, in retrospect perhaps it should have been left of the album?

One downside is that the album that, like Heart Full of Sky it’s missing Iain on keys. While Bryan’s keyboard playing has it’s moments, such as that dramatic extended instrumental section of the title track, much of the keyboard playing is workmanlike rather than exceptional, and there are certainly one or two places where over-simplistic piano parts drag an otherwise good song down. But as well as the keys I also find Bryan’s guitar playing a little too mannered. Although he does play a couple of great solos, they’re very structured and perhaps a bit too Gilmouresque for comfort. Nowhere does he really cut loose the way we’ve seen on the latest album “Go Well Diamond Heart”, and on earlier albums like “Storms Over Still Waters”. It almost feels as if Bryan was neglecting the guitar while he focused on keys.

Overall, it’s still a good album, and there’s a lot to like about it. In many ways it feels like a response to much of the criticism of Heart Full of Sky. I don’t think it’s anywhere close to the career-defining masterpiece some declared it to be at the time, but I do feel it’s a vast improvement on it’s somewhat flawed predecessor. In some ways it’s a pity the band weren’t as bold in playing as much of the album live during the 2008 tours as they had with “Heart Full of Sky” a year earlier; certainly I’d have loved to have heard the title track performed live.

This post originally appeared in a slightly different form on the Mostly Autumn forum.

Posted in Music | Tagged | Leave a comment

Classic Rock Society Awards

Great showing for both Mostly Autumn and Panic Room at the Classic Rock Society awards, where they all but swept the poll.

  • Best Female Vocalist: Olivia Sparnenn
  • Best Drummer: Gavin Griffiths
  • Best Guitarist: Bryan Josh
  • Best Album: Go Well Diamond Heart - Mostly Autumn
  • Best Track: Satellite - Panic Room
  • Best Band: Mostly Autumn
  • Best New Band: Parade
  • Best CRS Live Act: Mostly Autumn
  • CRS Personality: Anne Marie Helder

That’s a whopping five-and-a-half awards for Mostly Autumn!

While the CRS awards are less significant that things like the Classic Rock Presents Prog readers poll (in which MA and PR also did very well indeed, against far broader competition), it’s still a very strong endorsement of the new-era Mostly Autumn from a wider community than the hardcore fans.

This ought to serve as a reminder to the small but vocal minority of disillusioned former fans who don’t care for the new lineup that while they may be honest and sincere in their opinions, they are still in the minority.

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Mostly Autumn - Setlist Thoughts

Now that Mostly Autumn are shortly going to be heading back on the road, it’s time to post a few thoughts on what I’d like to see in the setlist.

I definitely applaud the band for playing a set with a high proportion of new material on the last tour. I also liked the way they rotated some of the older numbers rather than playing a near-identical set each night, something I’ve long advocated. Keeping the former Breathing Space song “Questioning Eyes” was a good move too.

I do, however. believe the running order could do with a rethink. I know from reading other’s reviews that I’m not the only one who thinks there’s not nearly enough of Livvy in the first half of the set. Look at the track listing of “Live 2009″ disk 1; Heather sings the first four songs. Also the balance between old and new didn’t quite seem right; the first set predominately oldies and GWDH disk 2 songs, the second set containing most of retail edition of the new album.

And I strongly the set ought to open with Livvy singing lead. While I’m defintely in the camp that considers “Go Well Diamond Heart” to be a strong album, the one thing it does lack is a belting hard rocker sung by Livvy. If reverting to “Fading Colours” as the opener seems too much of a backward step, what about “For All We Shared?”. It works well as an album opener, and they’re already using the beginning section as the intro tape. It’s not as dramatic a song as “Fading Colours”, but I remember when the band used to open with “The Last Climb”.

On the other hand, Bryan did say on stage at York that they planned to be writing new material in the lakes in January - perhaps they’ll surprise us all with something brand new?

As for other numbers, “Violet Skies” really ought to be in the setlist (I’m told it has been played live, but not at any gigs I’ve attended) and I’d love to hear “High” off the second disk. Wonder if “67-79″ would work live? I love the interplay between the guitar and flute on that. And while I know the band are most unlikely to play it, I’d still love to hear the title track of “Glass Shadows” played live. And finally, given that the majority of musicians who played on Liam Davidson’s excellent solo album are members the band, what about a song from that album? Of those songs, “Heading Home” gets my vote.

Posted in Music | Tagged | 2 Comments

Cambridge Rock Festival 2011

The 2011 Cambridge Rock Festival is looking like another good one! Return appearances by Panic Room and Chantel McGregor following their great sets last year; hopefully both will be higher up the bill. Mostly Autumn are on the bill yet again for the fourth year running.

And perhaps most significant of all, Heather Findlay will be playing with her new band, featuring Chris Johnson, Dave Kilminster, Steve Vantsis and Alex Cromarty, for what will be one of her first appearances as a solo artist. I remember some rather heated arguments on her forum over whether she ought to start off her solo career with high profile headline sets or to play some supports to build up an audience; it didn’t occur to anyone that she’s launch her career as a solo artist by playing some of the summer festivals. But it does make a lot of sense given that she won’t have a full album’s worth of material to promote.

Love to see both Stolen Earth and whatever Chris Johnson’s Parade (or whatever they’re renamed to now some “ciphers of budget rave-tinged Auto-Tuned dance muzak” backed by a lot of hype have stolen their name) on the bill. Stolen Earth are certainly up for it, and most of Parade will be there anyway.

Update: Not on the CRF website yet, but Stolen Earth are apparently now on the bill! Gets even better.

Posted in Music, Music News | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments